我剛剛是有到巴哈看一下沉默之丘的遊戲劇情
之前有位版友有po連結
他有沉默之丘設定的歷史...還不少東西

一開始是女孩夢遊提到某個地方，在剛開始母親也有跟父親提到女兒不是第一次提到這個地方
母親為了想辦法治療小孩(因為原本認養女兒的機構跟沉默之丘是來自同一地區，母親有上google找)
以為帶他到沉默之丘對女兒有幫助，因為她不想把女兒送去看精神科
然後劇情就這樣展開

在巴哈的劇情是說在沉默之丘的世界是由兩個人創造的
其中一個是灰濛濛的世界(我猜應該是在教堂的那個人創造的)
一個是黑暗的沉默之丘(由被火燒的阿蕾莎創造)
籠罩只能說是用遊戲中的手法吧
兩個世界在交替時發生的現象

遊戲的劇情跟電影的這部分劇情有差異
遊戲的劇情是說小女孩的生母要召喚墮天使的力量
可是因儀式失敗所以生出來的小孩阿蕾莎只有一半的能力
因此把女兒阿蕾莎關起來放火(他母親以為用肉體折磨的方式可喚醒另一半能力)
之後那個生母又想召喚一次~生出來的小孩卻被護士lisa送出去(這個小孩就是雪倫)
後來這個生母知道雪倫的下落，施法召喚雪倫來到沉默之丘
而這個生母創造一個跟沉默之丘一樣精神世界為了躲避警察對邪教的搜尋
在知道這件事的阿蕾莎創造了一個黑暗的沉默之丘
然後就開始劇情

而電影版的是指由小鎮一群人認為阿蕾莎是女巫而放火處死
被放火的阿蕾莎與惡魔訂下協議替自己復仇
後面母親那段跟惡魔的談話我記不太清楚
也不太清楚雪倫是怎麼來的(印象中是阿蕾莎的善良面？被惡魔送去育兒院，但為啥現在又要叫他回來？)
不過那個阿蕾莎的生母我好像有看到他對教堂的人說不要抓走他女兒的女兒(不曉得是不是我有看錯)
後半那裡文字劇情太多而且很快..沒來的及完全消化

這 第二首 就是了.

http://www.silenceisbroken.com/noiz/sh3main.php

不是這樣的吧
應該是護士聽到他們的對話
知道他已經死了
所以才在哭泣吧

以同理心來想，如果我是護士
要每天面對一個曾經把自己眼皮拔掉的人(其實已經是怪物了)
想逃也逃不掉，想自我了斷也沒辦法
觸目所及都只在那間噁心的房間以及燒爛的Alessa(想不看也沒辦法，其實可以用手遮啦XD)
這樣過了十幾年(不確定)
我覺得比知道自己死掉的事實還要讓人覺得難過吧
所以一直哭也是正常的吧...

阿蕾莎的生母好像沒有說不要抓他的女兒，但有表現出自己做了無可赦免的行為(沒有阻止村人抓走阿蕾莎。)所以這部份以及女主角老公的戲份算是改編出來且輔助說明內容...
至於黑暗淡出的方式以友人和我來說雖未玩過遊戲也無覺得不妥

我只記得那個生母有說過雪倫是她女兒的女兒...(印象中)
再加上那時她女兒(阿蕾莎)在班上同學罵他是巫女時跑到wc
又轉到清潔工的身上...
so我以為雪倫是被清潔工強暴後生下的
然後被惡魔帶到育兒所去

從影片中看起來也是這樣沒錯耶

但我有一個問題,
為什麼三十年前所主導火刑事件的那個女人(在教堂對大家宣教的女人)三十年後依舊如故,沒有老化的現像,如果進入了三十年前的世界,那麼在結局時的大屠殺時的鎮民為何只有那個主導事件的女人都沒有變化,其他人則是變成落迫的裝扮.........
復仇結束後,主角究竟是不是仍生存在,和阿蕾莎的生母是不是活著,開車離開時分明走在斷崖上,霧較淡的地方卻是車子走在公路上,憑空出現的斷崖究竟是為什麼,這麼大的斷崖難道是火山爆發嗎?
老公和警察進入鎮上時卻是晴空萬里,連下著灰的雪都沒有(不過他們沒有出現在山壁上的公路直接在橋上出現一直沒有走到過山壁的公路,說有找到車子,在那找的很怪異也沒講),
母女的景和父親的景完全不一樣,很以我也認定了,母女倆都死了,或者失蹤了,回到家的場景只是父親思念過多而己,我沒玩過電腦遊戲所以也不曉得遊戲是怎樣不過就電影而言,我覺的劇情在鋪陳上很棒,不過,,,,,這真的是真實事件改編嗎?很難相信,是真實的事件懸案

以下是yahoo上的網友所寫的…個人覺得解釋的相當清楚…

by stevienique (movies profile) Apr 22, 2006
862 of 936 people found this review helpful
**MAJOR SPOILERS** as I explain the entire movie for those of you who say it makes no sense...

Dahlia Gillespie had a daughter named Alessa. No one knew who her father was. Alessa was not liked by children or adults...a group of religious fanatics, led by Christabella, believed that this innocent was a witch and needed to be cleansed (that means killed)so that evil would not invade their community. Dahlia agreed because she was so fearful of this group and their promised damnation of her if she didn't agree. They burnt poor little Alessa, but the sacrifice went wrong and killed everyone in the cult...That's right, THEY'RE ALL DEAD...All of them are stuck in limbo...purgatory if you will. In this purgatory, Alessa's pain and anguish turn to hatred and a desire for revenge...Her hatred is so great that the bed ridden Alessa breaks off into two parts...Her dar side and everything that is light in Alessa. They don't want her light side to be overtaken by the hatred, so to protect her they take her to an orphanage...there is also another reason for this.

Rose and Chris Da Silva want to adopt a child. And although she's adopted, Sharon is Rose's daughter; She knew it from the moment she saw her...

But as Sharon gets older, she starts sleep walking and having nightmares about a place called "Silent Hill"...She is being called back by Alessa...the other part of herself, and she's supposed to bring Rose with her (because Rose is the one Alessa really needs)...so, Rose takes Sharon to the town of Silent Hill.

Along the way they meet up with a cop, Cybil Bennett, who is suspicious of Sharon's outburst...The movie even explains why Cybil would be so suspicious of something not that out of the ordinary; You see, in the past, she found a little boy dumped in a well by a psychopath and had to stay in the well with the boy until help came, to keep him from dying...so Cybil is probably almost paranoid when it comes to children...Cybil follows Rose and Sharon into Silent Hill an abandoned old coal mining town that is still burning underground...As soon as they enter the city limits, a ghostly figure of a girl runs out into the road in front of Rose's car and causes then to wreck...Could it be Alessa? Rose smacks her head hard...We later find out that Cybil wrecked and smacked her head as well...Hmmnn...

So, now they're in the town, so let's speed it up...Alessa's revenge is the darkness that turns everything dark and hellish...The siren on the church is to warn all the cult members to get to the church because the darkness can't get in there...Alessa sent her light part out so that she could bring someone back, like Rose, because Alessa needs Rose to take her into the church, because Rose can go into the church...where she can then finally get her revenge on those that mercilessly destroyed her...The only way that Rose could get into purgatory and help is by...that's right, by dying...Rose and Cybil both died in the accident. No Cybil wasn't needed by Alessa, she just basically got caught up in a bad situation. You can tell that they're dead because when Chris goes to the town with the cop, the town is abandoned, but completely normal and...this is the big one...Rose can run right through him...and at the end, that's why Rose and Sharon are still in the haze, but Chris is completely clear.

But no, there is a completely other level to this movie...Alessa was a sweet innocent that people decided was a hethen because she seemingly had no father...Sound familiar? The fanatics sacrifice her, but she comes back, almost as if resurrected...get it? She's almost crucified there at the end...there are rows of thorns (that would be the barbed wire) everywhere...So, those of you who love "The Chronicals of Narnia" because of it's deep religious message that comes from a Lion being resurrected by magic (and not a Heavenly Father)...and hate "Harry Potter" even though it is actually much more religious (in a poor boy being the savior of an entire people, but being hated by many simply for being who is and having to fight against an ultimate evil...sounds more like Jesus than C.S. Lewis' Lion to me)...You all should hate this movie, because it shows us what might have happened if Jesus had been pissed about his sacrifice and came back to seek revenge on those that killed him.

And yes, all of this IS explained in the movie...well, except the parallel to Jesus (I just thought that that was fairly obvious with the imagery)...This is what we call an intelligent movie. The filmmakers actually expected audiences to think and assumed that they had the capacity to do so. I understand that it can be confusing in this time of Paris Hilton and Jessica Simpson.

總之…其實Rose & Cybil在一開始時就已經出車禍死了..................