PCDVD數位科技討論區
PCDVD數位科技討論區   註冊 常見問題 標記討論區為已讀

回到   PCDVD數位科技討論區 > 數位影音討論群組 > 顯示設備討論區
帳戶
密碼
 

回應
 
主題工具
lienly
Senior Member
 

加入日期: Apr 2001
您的住址: TPE, TW
文章: 1,192
asus 42rw1[易錄fun], quick review [簡易測試]

10/31/2008, a dealer [at 民生東x段3角窗] with 3 asus sales reps. they demo 5 asus TVs, and key role is new 42rw1 [易錄fun].

asus reps [A]: this is newest and best TV in TW with DVR features.
L [that's me]: really? why you say it's the newest?
A: b/c so far no any other brand launches such TV/DVR here.
L: how come? LG launched it long time ago!
A: LG, doesn't count [b/c it's not TW brand] and not as good as ours [asus].
L: ok, TW first. then show me what it can do to be the best...
A: click some buttons to recall G-guide menu. see, you choose the show you want, then press 'green' key to timer record the show. just that simple/easy.
L: bit weird, b/c in every brand DVR 'red' mean record, why you change it to 'green'?
A: sigh.... let me show you its G-guide.
L: show me ch101[my favorite 淨空法師主講/華藏衛視], if G-guide is available?
A: ch101, see I told you our G-guide is the best, even ch101/102/103.... every channel has not only show time table, but brief show content intro for whole week.
L: hmm, this is good. b/c last year I tested another brand TV, it didn't have show info on later channels like ch101/102/103.....
L: how about POP, can you swap?
A: no problem, it can even zoom in/out.
L: how about none cable/DVBT sources, can it swap too?
A: oops, didn't know only L side can accept HD source...
L: does it have cc decoder?
A: what's it?
L: the chip can display hidden subtitle.
A: no, it's not required here.
L: what's its HDMI ver?
A: v1.3a! they reply with confidence!!!
L: so it supports xvColour/DeepColour.
A: never heard of what you just said......
L: how about CEC?
A: what's CEC?
L: do you know the differences of v1.3 vs v1.3a?
A: silent.....
L: then I don't believe it's v1.3. probably only v1.1 at most.
A: that's our RD told me, v1.3a.
L: which scaler it uses?
A: scaler, that's made by us, asus scaler.
L: what, really? since when asus makes its own scaler?
A: don't you know asus has big capital to make scaler.
L: pardon for my ignorance, but only know world top tier scaler makers like HQV, Faroudja, ABT, Marvel... hmm, this can be a headline breaking news! asus scaler...?
L: show me again how do you program the show I want to record.
A: as demo, very easy to setup timer record function.
L: say show A is 7-8, show B is 7:30-8:30. then how do you program it?
A: just do it like what we just did.
L: show me step by step to see how do you do.
A: they tried a few times but failed to make such programming.
L: didn't you just say it's that easy, how come you can't do it now?
A: sorry, it lacks such feature... can't overlap.
L: does TV has timeshift?
A: timeshift?
L: can I watch recorded show while record live show?
A: sorry, it can't.
L: how many tuners it has?
A: 2 analog + 1 DVBT.
L: DVBT HD?
A: no, only 15ch DVBT.
L: then can it record 2 shows simultaneously? [either cable + DVBT or 2 cables]
A: no, it can record 1 show at a time.
L: so what's 3 tuners for if can't record both?
A: just for you to watch 2 live shows.
L: how about overscan?
A: no problem, let me show you it can make 1080 pixel-2-pixel.
L: hmm, good, in every mode?
A: no, only PC mode.
L: does it have 120Hz or 10bits tech?
A: what for?
L: where is TV made?
A: at our factory, 龜山. MIT.
L: can user exchange HDD by himself?
A: no he can't. but TV has a USB port.
L: how to backup recorded show?
A: just move to USB, then use PC to duplicate.
L: can I delete unwanted ad?
A: you have to edit on PC.
L: can it record BS?
A: no, it can't handle BS.
L: how long is warranty?
A: 3 years full TV, includes remote.
L: how much is it?
A: MSRP $56900, but you can talk to dealer boss for better deal.

my comments:
its unknown scaler [or they claim asus made] doesn't give very smooth PQ.
Y/C separation isn't very good, somehow cross-coloured.
DVBT receiption is acceptable with little lag. [not sure if it's caused by traffic?]
remote has no backlit.
normal speed video is ok, but not good when show fast moving video. [that's why I am looking for 120Hz TV].
F/W design isn't so user friendly, not so advanced/matured/sophiscated as my many years old HRD2.
sales reps ain't so knowledgeable on products. 竟然被我這個毫無工科背景的一般用戶問倒了!

this TV isn't worth such big bucks!
you should buy a better TV with such budget or get a comparable TV + more user friendly DVR. unless you want all-in-one design TV/DVR.

believe here has some asus TV team members. if you read my post, you may answer some questions and teach your sales team to be more well trained.
     
      
__________________
某US喇叭品牌代理商, 他的囉囉們好像已經不再聽命於主人的命令了, 所以分道揚鑣.
現在甚至聽說該代理商已經突然無預警歇業關門了! 可能是惡有惡報, 週轉不良, 所以至今仍欠錢不還, 我就當成是佈施給窮的只剩下錢的老豬... 將來牠必定要再轉世為豬去償還債務的!

常收看 "淨空法師" 主講, "華藏衛視" 24Hr, 讓你煩腦滅, 智慧長. 善護口業不譏他過, 善護身業不失律儀, 善護意業清淨無染.
諸惡莫做, 眾善奉行. 善有善果, 惡有惡報, 不是不報, 時候未到.
世上什麼最真實? =>每個眾生, 一出生就勇往直前向墳墓邁進, 有什麼好爭的? 生氣是拿別人的錯誤來逞罰自己.
一切有為法, 如夢幻泡影, 如露亦如電, 應做如是觀. 真誠清淨平等正覺慈悲, 看破放下自在隨緣念佛.
舊 2008-11-04, 10:34 PM #1
回應時引用此文章
lienly離線中  


回應


POPIN
主題工具

發表文章規則
不可以發起新主題
不可以回應主題
不可以上傳附加檔案
不可以編輯您的文章

vB 代碼打開
[IMG]代碼打開
HTML代碼關閉



所有的時間均為GMT +8。 現在的時間是03:48 PM.


vBulletin Version 3.0.1
powered_by_vbulletin 2026。