瀏覽單個文章
貓花蝶同舞
Major Member
 

加入日期: Sep 2002
您的住址: 是誰把我的居住地偷改成【你感受得到我的地方]? 2003/07/14
文章: 281
Red face 百老匯舞台劇「貓」不同版本評論比較大集合!喵∼∼

各位貓友!

原本是在購買前,想先比較一下,可一次就買到正確版本,轉念一想,乾脆把做作業的過程與大家分享,讓其他尚未收到本劇的貓友都能利益均霑。

為了讓其他貓友能預先知道各版本差異,小弟在此把能找到的好萊塢音樂劇貓DVD的相關資訊列出,
有收藏不同版本的貓友如方便,是否願從同一畫面擷取幾張不同版本的螢幕照片,讓大家可以一眼看出各版的畫質與音質流量?
在此先謝過慷慨奉獻時間的貓友。

Cats Ultimate Edition (2 Discs)
Casts: Elaine Page, John Mills, Ken Page
Director: David Mallet
121 minutes, Universal
List Price: $ 26.98
Our Price: $ 21.54
Saving: 20%
Availability: Usually ships within 48 hours. FREE Shipping.

Major video release of the most famous stage musical of all time, based on fourteen poems from "Old Possum's Book of Practical Cats" by T.S. Eliot. Shot on Super-16 film over the course of a month at London's famed Adelphi Theater, the show was completely re-lit from scratch and was recorded in full stereo surround sound.

Note
Region 1 (US and Canada only)
Special Packaging Full Frame - 1.33 Single Side - Dual Layer Additional Release Material: Production Interview - 1. Cast & Crew Featurette - 1. "CATS Makeup Special" Interactive Features: Scene Access Interactive Menus

以下是同樣廠家出的另外一個版,跟上面那個版本由和差異呢?價格相近之下,哪個好呢?煩請哪位仁慈的貓兄相告!

CATS (COMMEMORATIVE ED.)
List Price: $ 29.98
Our Price: $ 20.49
Saving: 32%
Availability: Usually ships within 3 to 5 business days. FREE Shipping.
Cast: Elaine Page,John Mills,Ken Page
Directed by: David Mallet
Rating: Not Rated
Released by: Universal Studios Home Video
Runtime: 121 Minutes

Description
Major video release of the most famous stage musical of all time, based on fourteen poems from "Old Possum's Book of Practical Cats" by T.S. Eliot. Shot on Super-16 film over the course of a month at London's famed Adelphi Theater, the show was completely re-lit from scratch and was recorded in full stereo surround sound.

Note
Region 1 (US and Canada only)
Keep Case Letterboxed - 1.78 Single Side - Dual Layer Audio: Dolby Digital 5.1 - English Dolby Surround - English Additional Release Material: Featurette - 1. THE MAKING OF CATS Interactive Features: Interactive Menus

再加上高麗人蔘版無內頁說明與手冊外,台灣也有一隻貓,不知道跟國外相比,算得上是哪個版本才是真正好貓呢?
台灣版有無國語的歌詞翻譯字幕呢?還是只有英文字幕?歌詞翻譯是照實翻譯的直譯派?還是看不懂、翻不出來就亂掰美化派?

小弟當初冬園看戲前,咬了半天的牙,終於買下刊載歌詞的天價貓書。趁著觀眾入座妥當之前,在開幕前一翻,想在開演前臨陣磨鎗,先進入歌詞的情境氛圍,沒想到情緒立即墜入萬丈深淵,受到學習英文以來的最嚴重的打擊,因為歌詞中一大堆沒看過的古怪字眼。

後來才知本劇用了很多兒童用的狀聲詞、無意義的疊字,知道後才釋懷,原來不是我英文程度低落,這就是文化隔閡本身的詫異。

所以心中好奇想知道:台灣出的版本,中文歌詞翻譯水準如何?參雜了大陸味或是香港味嗎?

哪位可願意幫忙一下,回覆見教?多謝您幫忙!
     
      
舊 2003-04-13, 10:40 AM #1
回應時引用此文章
貓花蝶同舞離線中