引用:
|
作者jerry98225
炸彈怎麼拆我是不知道...我也沒看過炸彈...但是真正在伊拉克參戰的拆彈專家說的話總可信吧...去年看完片子後上IMDB討論... 該片被一些真正的拆彈退伍軍人罵的一踏糊塗..因為部隊裡不可能容許像男主角這樣的人在隊伍裡. 去年剛上映時總評也不過5點多分...上了奧斯卡提名後就暴升............
拆彈部隊是一個團體..不是個人秀..說什麼情緒極端之類的..真正再戰場上是不容許的...小弟我剛好有幾個參戰伊拉克最近回來休假的朋友...有看過該片的人都說跟事實有差距...而且是很大的差距......如果不相信我的話...最近聯合報上也有電影與事實差很多的報導.自己去找..該片除了軍服跟政治因素被攻擊之外...賣座濫...戲劇化的拆彈情節都被人拿來講..很多可以說咧....  |
轉自
http://www.hd.club.tw/thread-39010-3-1.html
美國拆彈老兵對拆彈部隊的看法
Why in the world is the Hurt Locker even in the same category as the rest of these movies? I am a soldier that has served in Iraq three times already, and escorting and being with EOD personnel has been my priority mission for at least 30 months while I have been there. I have served with at least 9 EOD teams from multiple branches of our fine military. So, my comment is who is the fu*$%ng idiot that thinks this is a good movie. In 2004 and today, EOD has NEVER worked the way they did in that movie. You see three of them go out on their own, BS! You see them drive out of their base and go many miles away, by themselves...BS! The list is long , but the whole movie is a bunch of crap and makes our EOD teams look like a bunch of wild cowboys that are OUT OF THEIR MINDS! I am sorry for anyone that really liked this movie, and thinks it deserves ANY of these OSCARS tonight! !
Respectfully,
A Soldier Proudly Serving
101st Airborne Division (Air Assault)
危機倒數憑什麼能夠和當晚的其他片子一起被提名？我是一名在伊拉克服務過多次的老兵。在過去的30個月裡，我的主要任務就是負責護送拆彈部隊。我和9個來及jun方不同部門的拆彈部隊一起執行過任務。我想說的是，到底是那個sb他媽的認為這是一部好電影？無論是在2004年還是在今天，拆彈部隊都沒有像片中那樣執行過任務。片中他們3個居然單獨行動，根本就是扯淡！你看到他們3個單獨駕車達到里基地數英里遠的地方，扯淡！我還可以列出一大堆硬傷。關鍵是，這部狗屎一樣的電影把我們的拆彈部隊表現的像一群發了瘋的牛仔一樣。如果你喜歡本片，或者認為它值得贏得任何奧斯卡獎項的話，我只能對你表示遺憾。
尊敬的，
一名正在服役的士兵
101空降師（空中攻擊分隊）