|
Senior Member
|
引用:
|
作者Crazynut
德佛札克交響曲第九號，一般推薦的版本多為庫伯列克的指揮。
入門書、評論裡大肆讚揚的，通常都是第二樂章，那個有"念故鄉"主題的樂章。
可我怎總覺得言過其實？我比較喜歡的是三、四樂章。
當然不可否認的，第二樂章的主題，在後面的樂章裡，還是有變奏出現，有其連貫性。
不過單純以單樂章的水準來看，我個人總感覺表現平平，無甚出奇之處。
|
我從沒聽過說評論說第二樂章最優 或是最好聽之類的
你誤會了第二樂章的所表現的意義
主要是在於引用了African-American的民謠 ( Wiki )
引用:
In a 2008 article in the Chronicle of Higher Education, prominent musicologist Joseph Horowitz asserts that African-american spirituals were a major influence on the 9th symphony, quoting Dvořák from an 1893 interview in the New York Herald as saying, "In the negro melodies of America I discover all that is needed for a great and noble school of music."[7]
Despite all this, it is generally considered that, like other Dvořák pieces, the work has more in common with folk music of his native Bohemia than with that of the United States. Leonard Bernstein averred that the work was truly multinational in its foundations.
|
這不是要說這個樂章最好聽或是比其他的樂曲都好聽 而是對古典音樂的發展上
好不好聽看人
每個人喜歡的音樂不竟然相同
你後面列的跟你前面的問題有什麼相干?
__________________
|