引用:
作者雷火豐
大哥,拜讀了一下您舉的例子,這是1989年 Neurology的paper,他們拿了54個檢體對醫師做測試,其中三個檢體是CJD。這是篇檢驗醫生分辨檢體(腦切片)熟不熟的paper,凸顯當時大家(包含醫生)對CJD都不熟,並不是每54個檢體就會有三個CJD...十年後醫生進步很大的
稍微拜讀一下wiki大神,CJD確診方法有三:
1.腦電波(可見三相突波)
2.腦脊髓液(可查蛋白質)
3.MRI
說實在的,這三項都不麻煩,要有人到死都誤診為阿茲海默症,很難
多年來CDC和WHO都建立CJD的標準檢驗法,到現在發生率還是每年每百萬人有1人
美國CJD每年的發生率 ( http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/dvrd/cjd/)
|
These three broad categories of symptomatic disease – mental or emotional deterioration, incoordination (especially of gait), and visual disturbance, alone or in combination – represent the earliest abnormalities in the great majority of patients with CJD, and their progressive severity over a matter of a few weeks is almost always cause for an initial medical contact (Table 1). Examination at this time may reveal surprisingly few objective physical signs, in spite of symptoms that to the patient are obvious, and this early disproportion between symptoms and signs has been responsible for a great deal of criticism of the medical profession by the families of patients with CJD, who ask (in retrospect) why the diagnosis was not considered earlier. The answer is that several more common diseases (especially Alzheimer’s disease) can mimic the early symptoms and signs of CJD, so that the physician is obliged to rely on the passage of time and progression of disease to winnow away these equally plausible alternative diagnostic possibilities.
也許是我英文不夠好
無法理解這段文字的敘述
請您看原文應該沒問題吧
我不確定有多少Alzheimer's Disease患者會去做這三樣檢查
在台灣光一個MRI就需要8000-16000的費用
(據了解, 健保對MRI有幾付)
不曉得美國會有多少人會為了確認 Alzheimer's Disease 與 CJD去做檢驗
而這三樣檢查也不是100%準確
None of these tests is sensitive enough to identify every case of CJD, and none is entirely specific for the diagnosis (Table 2); however, if two or all three of them are positive, the diagnosis is virtually certain to be CJD, no matter how atypical the illness, and no matter what the clinical supposition. Because of the availability of this battery of laboratory tests, brain biopsy is no longer needed or advised in the diagnostic evaluation of suspected cases of CJD.
Table 2. Laboratory aids in the diagnosis of transmissible spongiform encephalopathy.
Test Sensitivity Specificity
EEG 67% 86%
MRI 79% High
CSF (14-3-3) 91% 91%
Cerebral biopsy 95% 100%
到現在Alzheimer's Disease 與 CJD是比較容易被拿來做比較的
你以AD, CJD 當 keyword去搜尋paper就會發現