瀏覽單個文章
DanFang
*停權中*
 

加入日期: Aug 2000
您的住址: Seattle, WA
文章: 6,075
[轉貼]幾台23寸LCD評論

在Anandtech論壇看到的, 我不懂德文也拿不到這本雜誌故無法求證.
僅轉載別人的文章供有考慮這些螢幕的網友參考.
看起來現階段最佳選擇是Philips 230W5.

http://forums.anandtech.com/message...MVIEWTMP=Linear

halcyon
Junior Member

Posts: 1
Joined: 08/30/2004

c't magazine 20/2004 just did a review of 16:10 big tft displays. c't magazin is the best German computer magazine and not a trade rag like PC Mag or others, where you get a better review the more ad space you buy. These guys take their testing seriously. Many believe it is the best computer magazine in the world, considering their know-how and thoroughness.

The following displays all use the same S-IPS panel from LG-Philips.

Otherwise they were pretty similar, but the following differences were noted (sans cosmetics/casing/inputs):

Apple Cinema HD 23"
+ relatively slight grey-scale inversion
- Interpolation really bad

BenQ FP231W
- analog input is lousy
+ relatively slight grey-scale inversion

HP L2335
- not as good in grey-scale inversion as two above
+ pretty decent interpolation (better than the two above)
- not as good for gaming speed (As Apple & BenQ)

LG 2320A
- subjective quality not as good as above
- interpolation not among the best

Philips 230W5
+ decent interpolation
+ decent grey-scale inversion
+ decent gaming
= best or shared best in every category with this group of displays (S-IPS panel)

Sony SDM-P234B
- contrast less than others
= otherwise 2nd best in this group.

Samsung Syncmaster 243T (with Samsung PVA panel) was also evaluted. For static picture work it is clearly the best display of this group. However, it is not suitable for fast FPS gaming. It also has clearly inferior interpolation in the group (like Apple HD cinema).

The displays were all measured for contrast (min/max), standby-power, brightness (min/max), eveness of backlighting, refresh speed and then also subjectively evaluated with the naked eye.

Just FYI.
     
      
舊 2004-10-21, 03:20 AM #1
回應時引用此文章
DanFang離線中