[轉貼]幾台23寸LCD評論
 

在Anandtech論壇看到的, 我不懂德文也拿不到這本雜誌故無法求證.
僅轉載別人的文章供有考慮這些螢幕的網友參考.
看起來現階段最佳選擇是Philips 230W5.

http://forums.anandtech.com/message...MVIEWTMP=Linear

halcyon
Junior Member

Posts: 1
Joined: 08/30/2004

c't magazine 20/2004 just did a review of 16:10 big tft displays. c't magazin is the best German computer magazine and not a trade rag like PC Mag or others, where you get a better review the more ad space you buy. These guys take their testing seriously. Many believe it is the best computer magazine in the world, considering their know-how and thoroughness.

The following displays all use the same S-IPS panel from LG-Philips.

Otherwise they were pretty similar, but the following differences were noted (sans cosmetics/casing/inputs):

Apple Cinema HD 23"
+ relatively slight grey-scale inversion
- Interpolation really bad

BenQ FP231W
- analog input is lousy
+ relatively slight grey-scale inversion

HP L2335
- not as good in grey-scale inversion as two above
+ pretty decent interpolation (better than the two above)
- not as good for gaming speed (As Apple & BenQ)

LG 2320A
- subjective quality not as good as above
- interpolation not among the best

Philips 230W5
+ decent interpolation
+ decent grey-scale inversion
+ decent gaming
= best or shared best in every category with this group of displays (S-IPS panel)

Sony SDM-P234B
- contrast less than others
= otherwise 2nd best in this group.

Samsung Syncmaster 243T (with Samsung PVA panel) was also evaluted. For static picture work it is clearly the best display of this group. However, it is not suitable for fast FPS gaming. It also has clearly inferior interpolation in the group (like Apple HD cinema).

The displays were all measured for contrast (min/max), standby-power, brightness (min/max), eveness of backlighting, refresh speed and then also subjectively evaluated with the naked eye.

Just FYI.

23" LCD少見,評測似乎更罕見,謝分享資訊.

大尺寸顯示器(LCD,CRT,Projector都算),因為價格因素,本來的消費族群就屬於較少數的
再加上國外跟台灣因為消費族群數量差異太大,導致兩邊的價格差相當驚人
所以在國內,大尺寸顯示器使用的人並不算多
當然對於相關的討論就會比較少
很多國內外價差很大的商品,我常看到網友抱怨廠商不重視台灣,類似差別對待等等的回應
問題是看看國外,可能隨便一個州一個省,人口與整個台灣就可以相當
而人口與消費力通常是成正比的......
為了維持利潤與必要的開銷,結果就是一樣的東西,台灣要賣的比較貴
覺得不公平嗎?希望有這種觀念的網友能想想這些問題
(有感而發而已,別理我沒關係...... :stupefy: )

九郎兄,

說的好!不過我們台灣還是有很多物美價廉的產品.像數位相機,台灣的價格就真的很漂亮,還有配東西(如記憶卡之類的).美國這就沒有.價格死的很.

進來作做記號,
以後好查.....

小東西便宜
大東西貴


不過教科書和食品類,超級便宜

23"....

還真的是 Home Theater 的必備條件呀, 但是拿這麼大支的螢幕打電腦, 沒有一組銷魂的無線光學鍵鼠組似乎會累死你的眼睛呀............

翻譯過的教科書更便宜... :laugh:
有時還附解答. :yeah: :p

哈哈哈!同意!同意!同意!同意! :laugh:

不會喔,
現在都故意拆成上下二部.
加一加,大約八九成,


重點是用紙很爛.變成很大一本 :stupefy: