今天剛出爐的另一份 review, 是在國外玩家裡很有名的 oc-freak做的, 有上 cdfreaks的朋友們應該都知道他吧?

http://www.cdfreaks.com/article/226/1

取他在cdfreaks的 BenQ版上貼的一句話

"Overall the best drive on the market right now in my opinion"

"總的來說, 以我看來,這是目前市面上最好的燒錄機"

主要是代理商的問題，因為philips的燒錄機在台灣代理商不是philips本身

台灣的代理商很多都嘛是賣貨乾脆，售後服務再說...再說...

既然是一樣的設計、工廠，那就沒有必要找服務差的買

關於定價, 我是不大了解定價策略,
不過我想應該是跟著其他大廠的定價來走,

如果覺得台灣Benq賣太貴, 那應該是其他大廠在台灣也賣得貴
如果每家大廠在台灣賣得貴, 那一定是有什麼原因吧??
且....賣得說實在已經不貴了...

好多人在唱衰台灣廠商, 真怪...
總之, 台灣廠商加油吧.....

這個資料是舊的.
 

乍看之下, 覺得怪怪的, 跟之前印象不一樣, 連進去看一下.
果然, 大大 post 的是舊的投票了 - 2004 年.

新的是 2005.05 投的 , BenQ 變成第一名.

http://club.cdfreaks.com/showthread.php?t=135828

Which 16x DVD Writer Should I Buy? (MAY 2005)
- 問題 : 我應該買哪一台16x的 DVD 燒錄機.

投票結果 :

BenQ 37.32%
NEC 23.90%
LG 11.74%
Plextor 10.69%
Liten-On 9.43%
Pioneer 5.66%

雖然是最新的, 不過也好幾個月以前了, 那是 1620 pro 的年代. 1640 還沒出來.
比就有趣的, 先鋒在歐洲一直評價很差, 據說美國也不行.
好像只有大陸跟台灣比較受歡迎 - 至於日本市場, 我就不太清楚了.

下面是這次投票時( 2005.05 ) 的提示訊息.

BenQ:
* DVD write quality: Good and fast
* Reading: Good but slow (riplock can be removed by MCSE)
* Bitsetting: Yes
* PI/PIF scanning: Yes
* Misc: Good customer support/focus; official media overspeeding support (no need to use patched firmwares for overspeeding); the use of PCAV for 8x and 12x allows it to burn discs very fast, good 16x speeds, also

NEC:
* DVD write quality: Good (slow burning speeds at lower speeds)
* Reading: Good and fast (riplock can be removed with a hacked firmware)
* Bitsetting: Yes (requires hacked firmware)
* PI/PIF scanning: Yes (at the moment only in the 3520)
* Misc: Very poor customer support/focus, though there is a strong die-hard community that makes up for it; media overspeeding is available through the use of hacked firmwares; the use of ZCLV for 8x makes it the slowest burner when burning at 8x (though its 12x and 16x speeds are up to par)

LiteOn:
* DVD write quality: Average at 16x. Good at 12x or slower
* Reading: Excellent but slow (riplock can be removed with OmniPatcher)
* Bitsetting: Yes
* PI/PIF scanning: Yes
* Misc: One of the few DVD burners that excels at overcoming CD copy protections; strong community; hacked firmwares that allow for limited amounts of overspeeding; the use of PCAV for 8x allows it to burn 8x discs very fast, conservative 12x is a bit on the slow side, decent 16x speeds

Pioneer:
* DVD write quality: Good
* Reading: Good and fast
* Bitsetting: No
* PI/PIF scanning: Yes
* Misc: Strong community support (at rpc1.org)... >NIL:'s hacked firmwares allow for overspeeding; the A08/108's has gotten poor press about its ZCLV use (not just for 8x) and its 16x burn speed, which is slower than its 12x burn speed (effectively making the A08/108 more of a 12x burner than a 16x burner)

LG:
* DVD write quality: Good and fast (esp. with the latest models)
* Reading: Good, but there is a riplock (no hacked firmware to remove riplock exists yet)
* Bitsetting: Partial (not all plus media types)
* PI/PIF scanning: No
* Misc: Good customer support; no hacked firmwares for media overspeeding; DVD write speed can be quite good, depending on which model it is; newer models seem to do quite nicely in the 8x/12x/16x speed department...supports DVD-RAM

Samsung:
* DVD write quality: 552B poor/552U good
* Reading: Good but slow (no rip unlock)
* Bitsetting: No
* PI/PIF scanning: No
* Misc: Good CD-R write quality; good at CD copy protections; 552U has 6x +R DL; no hacked firmwares for media overspeeding

Plextor:
* DVD write quality: Good and fast (needs latest firmware)
* Reading: Good and fast (supplied software allows read speed increase)
* Bitsetting: Partial (not all plus media types)
* PI/PIF scanning: Yes (scanning software provided)
* Misc: Rich on features; Poor -R media compatibility; Good DAE speed; 8MB buffer; Expensive; no hacked firmwares for media overspeeding

原來我發表的是舊資料 :jolin: ，感謝銀河霸主大大的更正 ！
Pioneer 在台灣也漸漸不受歡迎了 ！

好的機器似乎跟產地有關
Benq 及NEC 都是MIM
其他幾乎都是MIC

1.請盡量少用"唱衰台灣"四字,因為這是某些既無能,且又無恥的"俗仔"的Excuse.
2.高價不代表高利潤,這道理總應知道吧! 就像單價較高的進口車,利潤不見的會
高於國產車一般,因為這跟取得的成本有關.

3."假設"在相同運送及管銷及製造成本之下,台灣廠商海外生產回銷台灣的DVD
商品,其關稅為5%,貨物稅10%,而進口舶來品的關稅為20%,貨物稅也是10%.

若BENQ 目前市價1800,而NEC 2000元,二個品牌代理商取得成本皆為台幣1200,
那BENQ在二稅加持之下,代理商多了186元的成本,而NEC的代理商則需支付384元,
二者在關稅與貨物稅方面,差了198元.

問題1:在此假設下,NEC的市價高於BENQ200元,價差是NEC代理商賺走了嗎?
問題2.單從您的認知與企業形象來看,您認為NEC與BENQ二者誰的製造成本高?
問題3.如果台灣開放所有進口商品免稅(如香港),一台日製Toyota collora 1.8
只要台幣30萬不到,有幾個愛護台灣廠商的,會想花50萬去買一台國產
Toyota Altis 1.8?

長期以來,台灣產業已經被政府關稅政策給過度保護,而衍伸出來的成本,就由全民
買單! 活生生的例子,就是國內幾大汽車廠以及油品公司. 在12000美元國民所得
基礎下,加這麼貴的汽油,看著台x四寶上半年盈餘破千億,這乃是搜刮民脂民膏而來,
難道有人還被騙不知?

上次買到1620p的地雷機現在看到1640評價很好..害我不知道要不要買下去怕又買到濫貨 比較想買nec3540... :flash:

我也是都有1620及1640兩台，感覺上1640比較好
1620常燒�***，不知是不是也是地雷機！