個人觀感問題.
就算你在不怎麼喜歡這部鳳凰令或者是周遭人怎樣,也是他們的問題.
你可以適當的表達自己的想法,而不是一直說看這部不如看其他電影來褒貶.
畢竟都是票房不相上下的電影,要怎麼去否定看過這兩部電影的人想的都跟你一樣?
前面有說過不喜歡看鳳凰令就夠了,用個人觀感來當作反對的原因一直討論下去也看不出有啥幫助,要就討論劇情吧.

看看昨天巴哈洽特在討論哈利波特為什麼會紅,裡面就有人用魁地奇的設定不合理與小說很多設定都與現實相比的不合理來批評這部小說不嚴謹.
但是這部奇幻小說你是想要求他寫到怎樣?這一開始只是設定是童書而已...(雖然後面開始走調)

既然您前面也已經充分的表達您對第5集的感想.
後面就不要一直抓著這論點來為了抗議而反對了吧,整串看完都是這種文章.
沒啥在討論電影劇情等等的,整串看完還真是有點失望.
雖然我都沒看過小說,但是電影每一部我都會去電影院看.(這周六要專程去看IMAX)
反而是變形金剛其他討論串就像在介紹新美軍武力大觀,卡通每一季我都有看可是電影嘛我等DVD再租就好了,可是我也不會一直用不喜歡這種片子來讚美哈利波特多好看.
既然要進哈力波特的討論串,自我約束並做良好的討論也是該自覺的吧?

好好好, 只要你不繼續耍寶講些低能的話,
偶也不想跟你這種沒水準的人一般見識!
不然這邊明明就是哈利波特討論,
你偏偏要沒水準的來當變型金剛,
是不想跟你見識! 但是你又在那猛酸, 猛洗板個不停,
偶要看的是哈利波特, 要看別人討論看了幾次變型金剛自然有另外很多個版面可以去,
你要水準?
那你可以去伊魯卡斯開的 se7en 板, 討論變型金剛讓你掉了多少淚水,
不要來這邊耍寶啦, 這是以 "哈利波特" 為主的討論,
來這邊自然就應該是 "哈利波特" 水平的人,
如果是要討論 "熱血好屌" 水平的人, 請自行蒐尋那其餘專屬的討論版面.



您果然是 "好屌" 充滿 "熱血" 阿!
您真夠水準了! 就是缺乏了對 "哈利波特" 版面的尊重,
還有發言亂不負責的,
滿口 "熱血好屌" 還在那談水準. 呵~

您好 你比較理性
我跟您討論 另一個低級的人的留言 我不打算回了

我沒有"一直"說哈利波特不好看
如果您願意花時間回頭去看 我會回言幾乎都是有人針對我回言我才回
就像你今天quote了我的發言 那我回你理所當然
除了針對回我言的人回言 我第二種會回言的原因就跟你一樣
討論一個是非問題 我從頭到尾也沒有說變形金剛多好看 也沒有比較
除了第一篇 我反應了我看到的真實情況
之後我並沒有在這兩部上多加著墨 而是像您一樣 看到走偏的發言 加以回應罷了
您如果找得出我在第一篇以外
有稱讚變型金剛 貶低哈利波特的文章 我從此閉嘴
如果沒有的話 是不是有太多人斷章取義 避重就輕 看到個影子就開槍的
甚至有些人沒水準到 不用一些低級的語言損一下別人來滿足他那張嘴的不行的人
這些人 又在討論劇情嗎?

"熱血好屌" 的變形大金剛,
閉嘴吧!

喔.. 忘記了, 你的水準是不會對自己的言與負責的!



是是是, 您熱血好屌, 屌的有水準!



ㄟ. 熱血好屌, 第二次耶!
是因為屌血衝腦所以沒印想了嗎?



熱情熱血好屌第三次啦!,
大家什麼表情? 看到熱情熱血好屌的表情嗎?



熱情熱血好屌, 你一根屌就已經屌了至少四次啦!



不用很多人耶, 只要一根熱情熱血好屌就可以講四次,
夠瞎了! 屌到瞎了.



熱情熱血好屌, 第五次了還停不下來喔!
不同就不要比了,
屌來屌去的好熱情喔?
這五次都算根 "屌" 在發言的話, 的確是沒什麼 "人" 在用變型金剛去貶低哈利波特喔!


喔.. 忘記了, 你的水準是不會對自己的言與負責的!

當討論串淪為丁丁用來謾罵的地方時
這討論串就已經廢掉了....

何必.....
再把它撐起來就好啦！ :D


電影中的一些疑點沒有講清楚....
為什麼一開始守衛會去攻擊一般人跟哈利，而之後的調查到底查出來了沒有？
夫子對於黑魔王的到來採取否認的態度，電影中說是恐懼所致，雖然有點牽強.....那恩不理居支持夫子的背後因素是什麼？
還有監獄為什麼會破掉？人犯還可以跑出來？ :confused:

催狂魔記得以前就被佛地魔驅使過
所以佛地魔可以輕易的指使催狂魔去攻擊哈利波特

至於夫子和恩不理居....從政治來看就很清楚了
一個不想因為發生重大災害(黑魔王�**{)而下台,
一旦法力更強的校長進佔魔法部長職位, 那夫子就失勢(不是去勢)啦

恩不理居可以想成政治領袖的支持者
而且從學校裡的種種作為來看, 她也是蠻享受權力的人物

至於監獄....佛地魔掌控催狂魔
沒有了催狂魔, 監獄就不再是監獄了

"Umbridge first appears in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, as Senior Undersecretary to the then-Minister for Magic, Cornelius Fudge. As a senior undersecretary, she is one of Harry Potter's interrogators in Courtroom Ten as part of the Wizengamot, the wizarding judicial committee, when he is tried on charges of breaking the ban on underage sorcery. It is later revealed that Umbridge herself had ordered Dementors to attack Harry in an attempt to silence or frame him. He repelled them using the Patronus Charm and was thus entrapped into using magic for self-defence, which would have worked to Umbridge's advantage had it not been for Arabella Figg's testimony, Albus Dumbledore's defence and Amelia Bones's fairness." (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dolores_Umbridge)

"Fudge is particularly paranoid that Dumbledore is a threat to his power, and that he is, in effect, planning to train the Hogwarts students loyalty to himself rather than the Ministry and in effect overthrow Fudge. Ultimately Fudge manages to have Dumbledore removed as Headmaster and Umbridge put in his place, but this is overturned after the Battle of the Ministry, which proves Voldemort's return to power and destroys Fudge's political career.

When his failure to admit Voldemort's return comes to light, Fudge is forced to resign as Minister for Magic and replaced by Rufus Scrimgeour in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, though he stays on as a powerless advisor.

According to Hagrid, after Millicent Bagnold (Fudge's predecessor) left office, Dumbledore was the most popular man to succeed her, but refused himself, preferring to remain at Hogwarts. Fudge thus knew for his entire tenure that he was less popular, and also apparently that he was less qualified---Dumbledore was apparently an informal advisor to Fudge, with Hagrid claiming Fudge sent numerous owls asking Dumbledore for advice. This knowledge of Dumbledore's superior popularity and skill was likely one of the reasons for his actions after Voldemort's rise; in addition, it is implied that Fudge simply did not want to believe that Voldemort could return, knowing that that would be the end of the Wizarding world's years of peace, and decided to merely ignore all of the evidence rather than accept the truth. Fudge could thus be based loosely on Neville Chamberlain, the British Prime Minister who attempted to ignore Adolf Hitler's rise to power, believing that doing so would prevent war, while Scrimgeour could be seen as Winston Churchill." (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cornelius_Fudge)

沒想到他們有些人長那麼高，真的從電影中看不出來喔~~呵呵 :agree:

哈利179我不信 :jolin: :jolin: